Top Four U.S. States with the Highest Auto Insurance Costs

This article highlights the four U.S. states with the highest auto insurance rates, exploring factors like proximity to urban centers, insurance policies, and fraud contributing to elevated premiums. It provides insights into regional differences affecting drivers' costs nationwide.

Top Four U.S. States with the Highest Auto Insurance Costs

Are your car insurance premiums surprisingly steep? If your driving history is clean, your location might be the main factor. Certain states in the U.S. face higher insurance rates due to factors like elevated theft rates, personal injury claim fraud, and proximity to major urban centers.

Here's a list of the four states with the highest auto insurance premiums in the country...

1. New York

Residents across New York, from bustling cities to rural areas like Buffalo, often pay annual premiums exceeding $2,500, sometimes nearing $3,000.

For instance, drivers in New Jersey face higher costs partly due to their proximity to New York City.

2. Michigan

Many appreciate Michigan's natural beauty but tend to avoid residing there because of high insurance premiums. Detroit's elevated car theft rate contributes, but the main driver is Michigan's no-fault insurance system, which covers all medical expenses and 85% of lost wages after accidents, regardless of fault.

Fringe issues like personal injury claim fraud are prevalent, leading to numerous fabricated accidents.

3. Connecticut

Although just a short drive from New York City, Connecticut's car insurance costs are high, averaging over $2,700 annually. Its proximity to New York influences these elevated premiums.

4. Florida

The Sunshine State's warm climate and long periods without snow don't prevent high insurance costs. Widespread personal injury protection (PIP) fraud results in significant payouts—costing around $1 billion annually—despite insurance limits.

Explore