Understanding Home Warranties: Advantages and Drawbacks
Learn about the advantages and limitations of home warranties. Discover how they protect homeowners from unexpected repair costs, when to consider purchasing one, and what potential drawbacks to be aware of before committing. This guide helps homeowners evaluate if a home warranty suits their needs and how to navigate the process effectively.

A home warranty is a service contract that covers repairs and replacements of essential household systems and appliances for a specified period. It acts as an agreement between a homeowner and a provider, ensuring discounted repairs or replacements for key home components. Buyers often choose a home warranty when purchasing older homes without detailed maintenance records.
How a Home Warranty Functions
When acquiring a home, it's important to know how well the previous owner maintained its systems and appliances. Often, this information isn't readily available, making repairs costly and time-consuming. A home warranty alleviates these concerns by covering major repairs, saving homeowners from surprise expenses. While similar to home insurance, warranties focus on wear and tear, not damage from disasters. Coverage typically includes appliances like refrigerators and stoves, and sometimes HVAC or plumbing. Always review the policy thoroughly for specific inclusions and exclusions. When an issue arises, homeowners contact the warranty provider, who coordinates with service contractors to assess and repair or replace the affected component.
Choosing a Home Warranty
Claims can be denied, especially if damage existed before coverage started. It's wise to get a pre-purchase inspection to identify existing issues. Warranties don't cover poor maintenance or improper installation. Builders may offer structural warranties lasting years, and sellers often include a one-year warranty with resale homes, sometimes paid for by the seller.
Cost Breakdown
Generally, home warranties cost between $350 and $600 annually, with optional add-ons increasing the price by $100-$500 based on coverage extent. Homeowners also pay a service fee per repair, usually $50-$100, which acts as a deductible. Replacement costs exceeding coverage limits fall to the homeowner. Multiple repairs can incur multiple service fees.
Benefits of a Home Warranty
A home warranty provides peace of mind against unexpected repair costs, especially for homeowners without emergency savings or with busy schedules. It offers protection for major systems and appliances, particularly for older homes or newly built properties. Warranties can be a selling point, reassuring buyers about home condition. Sometimes, sellers include warranties to facilitate sales.
Limitations to Consider
Home warranties have restrictions. They often exclude poorly maintained items, leading to disputes over what constitutes proper upkeep. Past damage to aging appliances may not be covered, even if current maintenance is good. Coverage limits and exclusions could leave homeowners paying out of pocket for significant repairs. If repairs are minor, the warranty might not be cost-effective compared to setting aside savings. Additionally, homeowners can't choose their contractors or parts, and may be limited in replacement options, which can impact satisfaction. The process of dealing through a third-party warranty provider can also complicate repairs. Before opting for a warranty, homeowners should weigh benefits against potential limitations and thoroughly vet providers. If a seller offers a warranty, it can be beneficial, but buyers should still conduct inspections and due diligence.